Executive Function Intervention: Why Scaffolding & Collaboration Matter

therapist smiling at child while they are working together

When building executive functioning in children and young people, there are two important therapeutic considerations we need to balance. Scaffolding and collaboration.  Scaffolding is how we support thinking, and collaboration reflects how we engage the child or young person during the process of thinking. 

What Is Scaffolding?

Scaffolding refers to the support we provide others to help them complete tasks they are unable to do independently at that time.  For example, scaffolding executive functions can assist children and young people to use and practice skills which are still developing, such as planning, problem-solving, inhibition, or self-reflection, in order to complete tasks as independently as possible.

Scaffolding might include:

  • Prompting

  • Modelling 

  • Questioning

  • Providing cues

  • Encouraging reflection

  • Breaking tasks into manageable parts

When we scaffold we should also be considering how to adjust the amount of support provided to gradually transfer responsibility over time. Scaffolding should provide enough support to complete a task successfully, while still allowing them to do as much of the thinking as possible themselves. This is similar to the concept of working within a child's zone of proximal development, where support enables them to achieve more than they could independently.

What Is Collaboration?

While scaffolding is the ‘what we do’, collaboration is the ‘how we do it’.  

Collaboration typically involves:

  • Inviting the young person into our discussion from the start 

  • Shared decision making

  • Understanding the child's perspective

  • Engaging the child directly in problem-solving

  • Respecting their expertise in their own experiences

  • Co-creating strategies and the way forward together 

Using a collaborative approach can assist by engaging the young person in therapy, rather than them feeling they are having therapy delivered to them. By assisting with creating a sense of “buy-in” from the young person, using a collaborative approach also has the benefit of building motivation in the young person to engage with strategies they help co-create. 

The Risk of Scaffolding Without Collaboration

It is possible to scaffold without being particularly collaborative. For example:

"I've decided you need a visual routine to help you get out of the house on time. I’ve made this and put it on the fridge for you. Let me show you what this looks like...”

The adult may be providing excellent support, prompts, reminders, and structure. The task gets completed and the child may experience success. However, the child or young person has had very little involvement in understanding the problem, generating ideas, or evaluating whether the solution works for them.

So while this might assist with the child’s executive function differences in the short term, the child has not practiced or learnt how to apply these steps themselves. This is particularly important when we are wanting a child or young person to develop their executive functioning skills, as an important part of executive function development is the opportunity to practice and build these skills. 

The goal of scaffolding when providing executive function support is not to keep the young person reliant on an adult to provide scaffolds, but to gradually teach them the skills to be able to understand how they can support themselves.

The Risk of Collaboration Without Scaffolding

At the other end of the spectrum, it is possible to be highly collaborative without providing enough support for executive functioning. For example:

"What do you think would help?"

This question demonstrates respect for the child's perspective and encourages ownership. However, for a child with significant executive functioning challenges, it may also feel overwhelming.

They may not yet have the self-awareness, planning skills, working memory, or problem-solving abilities needed to answer the question effectively.  In these situations, using collaboration alone can unintentionally place too much responsibility on the child before they have the skills or support required to succeed.

Where the Real Growth Happens

The most effective support in executive function development often comes from combining both scaffolding and collaboration. 

Rather than telling children what to do, or expecting them to figure everything out alone, we collaboratively scaffold the executive function process. This supports children and young people to engage in the thinking that sits behind successful problem-solving and strategy use.

If we simply give solutions, the child experiences the outcome but doesn't necessarily practise the thinking.  If we simply ask them to solve the problem independently, they may not have the capacity to do so.

Instead of saying: 

 "Here's what you need to do."   or  "What do you think would help?"

We might say things like: 

 "I wonder what’s making this hard for you?..... What have you already tried?... What happened then?... Would it help if we brainstormed some ideas together?"

When we collaboratively scaffold the executive function process, children and young people are not simply given strategies to use. They are repeatedly supported to engage in the executive function processes that sit behind strategy use such as:

  • noticing a problem

  • defining the problem

  • reflecting on previous attempts

  • generating options

  • evaluating options

  • planning

  • monitoring

  • reviewing outcomes

Initially, the therapist carries a lot of that cognitive load, so provides a high level of support. Over time, the child participates more and more in the executive function processes. For some children and young people, over repeated exposure and practice, the processes may become internalised. For others, they may need continued support to follow a routine that assists them to use their executive function processes. 

Conclusion

The aim of executive function intervention is not to simply solve the immediate problem, but to help children and young people develop the executive function processes that allow them to create, select, trial, adapt, and evaluate strategies independently over time.

And collaborative scaffolding provides a practical way to help children practise the executive function processes that sit behind successful strategy use.

If you don’t already, I encourage you to use a collaborative scaffolding approach in your interactions with young people.  To help you out, download my cheat sheet of scripts*: “Collaborative Scaffolding Scripts that Support Executive Function Processes”

*Subscribe to the Dandelion Hub newsletter to access this and other free resources and receive practical, neuroaffirming executive function insights, strategies, and updates. Unsubscribe at any time.

Already subscribed? Simply enter your details again to access these resources. You won't receive the Dandelion Hub newsletter twice.

Next
Next

Supporting Executive Function Development Through Play: An Early Intervention Perspective